Unfair Dismissal

HR and Employment > Employers > Unfair Dismissal

Defending unfair dismissal claims

Unfair Dismissals claims can be stressful and complex for employers.

Our expert team of Employment Law Solicitors are experienced in handling such claims for employers, helping you to navigate the process and resolve the situation as speedily and as cost effectively as possible. This may include negotiating a settlement as well as defending a claim in the Employment Tribunal.

Unfair Dismissals usually arise are when an employee is fired from their job without a substantial or fair reason or if the employer fails to follow a fair procedure in doing so. If your former employee had brought an Unfair Dismissal claim against you, please see the section below about the potential resolutions to the claim and get in touch with our Employment Law team today for a no-obligation conversation.

Potential Resolutions to Unfair Dismissal Claims

Unfair dismissal claims are serious situations and can cost businesses and claimants many thousands of pounds in direct costs.

Our expert team of Employment Law Solicitors are well equipped to help employers find the best possible resolution from through either a settlement agreement or Employment Tribunal.

Settlement Agreement:

If both parties choose to settle the claims that have been raised then a Settlement Agreement can be used to end the dispute and come to a fair resolution, without involving an Employment Tribunal that would be a long and costly process for both parties.

Employment Tribunal:

If either party does not wish to settle the dispute then the claim will go to an Employment Tribunal where both parties will need legal representation in order to try and win the dispute and secure the best possible outcome.

Unfair Dismissals FAQs

What is Unfair Dismissal?

The right to claim unfair dismissal is a right given to qualifying employees to give them some protection against losing their job without good reason. An unfair dismissal is a dismissal that is not fair becuase the correct procedure wasn’t followed and/or the employer did not have a fair reason to dismiss the employee.

Who can bring a claim of unfair Dismissal?

Only employees can claim that they’ve been unfairly dismissed. The right doesn’t extend to workers or those who are self-employed.  The employee will need to be dismissed, and in most cases, they will need to have worked for their employer continuously for at least two years, although there are some limited exceptions to this rule.

What are the reasons for dismissal where two years’ service isn’t needed?

The general rule in unfair dismissal cases, is that the employee needs to have worked for their employer for two years at the time of their dismissal, to be entitled to bring a claim. But, there are some exceptions to this.  If an employee is automatically unfairly dismissed, they will not need to show that they have been employed for two years. Automatic unfair dismissal occurs when an employee loses their job for a certain reason, including:

  • In connection with them carrying out jury service
  • Connected to pregnancy, childbirth or statutory leave, such as maternity leave, paternity leave, adoption leave, parental leave, shared parental leave, time off to attend antenatal appointments or adoption appointments, or time of for dependants
  • For a Health and safety reason
  • In connection with Sunday working
  • Connected to rights under the Working Time Regulations
  • For acting as an employee representative, pension representative or occupational pension trustee
  • For blowing the whistle
  • Relating to the national minimum wage
  • For asserting a statutory right
  • Connected to minimum wage
  • In connection with an application for flexible working
  • For being a trade union representative or member
  • taking part in legal, official industrial action for 12 weeks or less, for example going on strike
  • In connection with the exclusivity clause in a zero hours contract

What are the differences between Dismissal and Constructive Dismissal?

For an employee to claim unfair dismissal, they must first show that they’ve been ‘dismissed’.

The dismissal may be an actual dismissal, where the employer ends the employee’s contract of employment, with or without notice.  This can be done in writing, or the employer may just tell the employee orally that their employment is to come to an end. 

Or, the employee may be able to show that they’ve been ‘constructively’ dismissed. This is where the employee resigns on the back of the employer breaching a fundamental term of their contract of employment, and then they ‘construct’ a dismissal out of their resignation.  The term that the employer breaches must go to the heart of the employment relationship, and it can be either an express term, such as the obligation to pay the employee, or an implied term, such as the implied term of mutual trust and confidence. 

Can I be Unfairly Dismissed Without a Written Contract?

Yes, you can.  All employees are employed under a contract of employment. In most cases it is a written contact of employment.  But, in some cases the employer won’t give the employee a written contract of employment, in which case they’re employed under an oral contract of employment.  Either way, if an employee is unfairly dismissed, they’re entitled to bring a claim for unfair dismissal.   

What is unfair Dismissal Compensation?

If an employee wins their claim for unfair dismissal at an Employment Tribunal, the tribunal can award them compensation.  The amount of money the employee receives depends on a number of factors, including how long the employee worked for the employer, how much they earned, what type of work they did, and how long it took them (or will take them) to find a new job.

Each case will depend on its own facts, but in most cases the employee will be awarded compensation under the following heads:

Basic award

This is awarded to compensate the employee for being unfairly dismissed and is calculated in the same way as a statutory redundancy payment, follows:

  • One and a half weeks’ pay for each year of employment after age 41.
  • One week’s pay for each year of employment between ages 22 and 40.
  • Half a week’s pay for each year of employment under the age of 22.

Up to a maximum of £643 per week.

Compensatory award

This is to reflect the financial losses the employee has suffered as a result of their unfair dismissal.  If the employee has a new job, then their losses will be reduced by the amount they are earning in their new role.  The tribunal will decide how long it thinks the employee will take to get back into the position they were in prior to being dismissed, and put a corresponding long-stop on the period for which they can claim losses.

Loss of statutory rights

This is to compensate the employee for the fact that, before they were dismissed, they were a protected employee (i.e. they had two years’ service and could claim unfair dismissal), but for at least the next two years they won’t be a protected employee.

Wrongful dismissal/breach of contract

This is compensation for the notice pay the employee should have received if they weren’t paid for the whole of their notice.

The amount an Employment Tribunal can award is capped at the lower of one year’s gross pay for the employee, of £105,707.  There are some cases where the cap doesn’t apply, such as whistleblowing cases and health and safety cases, but they’re definitely the exception rather than the rule.

How can a dismissal be fair?

A dismissal will be fair if it is (1) for one of the five potentially fair reasons and (2) a fair process is followed.  The potentially fair reasons are:

1. Capability or qualifications – If an employee is being dismissed because of their capability or qualifications, the employer should ensure:

  • the employee knew what was required of them
  • the employer took steps to minimise the risk of poor performance
  • there was a proper appraisal of the employee and the problem was identified
  • they provided training, supervision and encouragement
  • they warned the employee of the consequences of them failing to improve
  • they gave the employee a chance to improve, and
  • they considered alternative employment, if appropriate

 2. Conduct – A dismissal on the grounds of conduct will only be fair if at the time of the dismissal, the employer believed the employee to be guilty of the alleged misconduct. The belief must be based on reasonable grounds following a reasonable investigation. The employer will need to show that they’ve carried out a reasonable investigation, set out the allegations, given the employee a chance to defend them, and given them a chance to appeal.

3. Redundancy – It’s unlikely that a redundancy dismissal will be fair unless the employer has:

  • Warned and consulted any affected employees (or their representatives)
  • Adopted a fair basis on which to select the employees for redundancy, and
  • Taken such steps as may be reasonable to avoid or minimise redundancy by redeploying potentially redundant employees within its own organisation

4. Breach of a statutory restriction – If a dismissal for this reason is to be fair, the restriction will need to be severe and the employer will need to consider any alternative positions the employment can as an alternative to dismissal.

5. Some other Substantial Reason – this is a ‘catch all’ category.  If the employer wants to make the dismissal fair, they’ll need to consult with the employee, explore alternatives to dismissal and give the employee a chance to state their case, before they are dismissed.

Employment Law Specialists at Atkins Dellow

Related Insights

Still Need Help?

Call 0330 912 8338 to have a chat with our Employment Law Team